| December
1, 1994© |
Paul J. Breaux completed
Pharmacy School in 1965. After practicing pharmacy
for several years, he entered L.S.U. Law School,
graduating in 1972, and he has practiced law since
then. His practice is located in Lafayette, Louisiana. |
When a person is performing some act that is
intended to be an act of a corporation, that person must make
certain that those with whom he is dealing are aware the act
is one by the corporation and not an act of his individually.
Carelessness and inattention can make you liable personally
for a debt of a corporation. A defendant in a recent case
learned that lesson in a costly way.
The case involved a lease of a building. The written lease
recited that the parties were "R. H. Wilkinson, as Lessor,
and Suntan's Unlimited, as Lessee." The signature line
of the lease described the lessee as "Suntan's Unlimited,
By: Val Sweeney." Suntan's Unlimited was not described
as a corporate entity anywhere in the body of the lease, and
nowhere in the lease was Sweeney referred to as appearing
and acting as an officer of a corporation. Nevertheless, when
the lessee paid the rent each month, it was with checks drawn
on a checking account of the corporation, those checks clearly
identifying the lessee as "Suntan's Unlimited, Inc."
The lessee defaulted on the rent after eight monthly payments
and the lessor filed suit against Val Sweeney personally.
The court described the issue as being whether Sweeney had
met the affirmative duty imposed on him by law to disclose
to Wilkinson that Sweeney was acting on behalf of the corporation.
The court stated that "it is imperative that one claiming
the benefit of corporate capacity, in order to avoid personal
liability, be shielded with the proper documentation ... to
prove this capacity." Being unable to find the proper
documentation, the court held Sweeney personally liable for
the lease payments.
Taking proper precautions at the beginning of a business
or other contractual arrangement will nearly always prevent
unintended consequences at the end. Had Sweeney been careful
at the outset, he probably would have been successful defeating
any personal liability. At the very least, Sweeney should
have insisted the body of the written lease describe the lessee
as "Suntan's Unlimited, Inc.," and should have insisted
that the signature line of the lease describe the lessee as
"Suntan's Unlimited, Inc., By: Val Sweeney, President."
People should never assume in their commercial or business
transactions that the person with whom they are dealing is
schooled in the way a corporate party to a transaction must
be described. Even though you may have made it clear throughout
the course of weeks or even months of off and on negotiations
with a particular person that your actions are on behalf of
a corporate entity, you simply must be on your guard through
to the very end, you must take sufficient time with the written
contractual documents before you affix your signature.
Courts have held time and time again that "a person's
signature on a document is not there as an ornament, or ornamentation."
That is, if a contractual obligation is signed by "Val
Sweeney," then it is Val Sweeney who is obligated; and,
if the document is signed by "Val Sweeney, as President
of Suntan's Unlimited, Inc.," then it is only Suntan's
Unlimited, Inc., that is obligated.
Even if the person with whom you are dealing on behalf of
your corporation, for example a banker about a business loan,
insists that you take on personal liability for the performance
of the transaction, you should still negotiate for a loan
by the bank to your corporate entity, with your entering into
the transaction only as a personal guarantor. With the passage
of time, you may one day be able to renew the loan without
your personal guarantee.
Not only must you thus be thorough and mindful to create
and maintain all the appropriate internal corporate records
once incorporated (such as minutes of shareholder and director
meetings and other corporate board resolutions), you must
be vigilant to always be clear and unambiguous with your corporation's
"external" documents, too, such as contracts, loans
and other written agreements it enters into with third persons
and others of the general public.
If you are not clear with the public and have been careless
and inattentive, you can find yourself faced with personal
liability for an obligation that you never intended and possibly
even the other party with whom you dealt initially did not
intend either.
|
|